“Improving Peer Review of Systematic Reviews and Related Review Types by Involving Librarians and Information Specialists as Methodological Peer Reviewers: A Randomised Controlled Trial” by Melissa L. Rethlefsen et al.
An RCT of 400 systematic reviews found that adding librarians as reviewers didn’t improve search reporting or reduce bias, but was linked to higher manuscript rejection rates. What does that say about systematic reviews — and peer reviewing?
[BMJ Evid Based Med 2025;30(4):241-249]